Do you make a cup of coffee at home and taste something sharp, almost vinegary, instead of a full, round cup? Then chances are your coffee tastes sour because of the way it's brewed, not because of the beans themselves. In this article the baristas at SIJL in Assen explain why coffee can taste sour, how that differs from the pleasant, fresh acidity that belongs to specialty coffee, and how to fix it step by step.
What does it mean when coffee tastes sour?
You usually notice sour coffee as a sharp, thin flavour that prickles on the sides of your tongue, sometimes similar to the taste of unripe fruit or vinegar. This is almost always a sign of under-extraction: too little has been drawn out of the ground coffee during brewing.
Under-extraction happens when the water flows past the coffee too briefly, too quickly or too cold. The acids in coffee are the first to dissolve during extraction, followed by the sweeter compounds and those that give more body. If the process stops too early, you mainly taste sourness and miss the balance of sweetness and body that makes a good cup of coffee so enjoyable.
What are the most common causes of sour coffee?
A grind that's too coarse
If your coffee is ground too coarsely, the water runs through it too quickly and doesn't have enough time to dissolve the flavour compounds properly. This is by far the most common cause of a sour cup of coffee at home.
Every brewing method calls for a different grind size: an espresso machine needs finely ground coffee, a cafetière needs a coarse grind. Not sure about the right setting? We've written a detailed overview in grinding coffee: the right grind size for each brewing method.
Too little extraction time
If your filter coffee or V60 runs through in a few seconds instead of two to four minutes, the water simply hasn't had enough time to extract the coffee properly. A coarser grind and too short a brew time often go hand in hand.
Water that isn't hot enough
Brewing coffee with water below 90°C means the acids do dissolve, but the sweeter, fuller flavour compounds stay behind. For most brewing methods, water between 92 and 96°C is ideal, so just below boiling point.
Too little coffee for the amount of water
If you use too little ground coffee for the amount of water, your cup as a whole is under-extracted and the sour taste stands out even more. A good rule of thumb for filter coffee is about 60 grams of coffee per litre of water, and we explain that ratio step by step in brewing filter coffee: how to get it right at home every time.
Freshly ground coffee that's left standing too long
Ground coffee starts losing aroma within minutes, and with it the balance needed for a good extraction. So grind just before you brew, and always use freshly roasted beans.
How do you fix sour coffee? Step by step
Do you recognise one of the causes above? Then follow this order to get your coffee in balance.
First grind your coffee a little finer and brew again with the same amount of water and coffee. If the taste is still sharp, lengthen the extraction time by pouring more slowly or letting the brew run a little longer. Then check the temperature of your water: let boiled water stand for about thirty seconds before you pour it over the coffee. Finally, weigh your coffee and water instead of estimating, so you use the same, reliable ratio every time.
Is a little acidity in coffee actually bad?
No, a fresh, lively acidity is a hallmark of good specialty coffee, not a flaw. The difference is in the taste: sharp and vinegary points to under-extraction, while fresh and fruity belongs to the bean itself.
Lightly roasted coffee beans from higher-altitude origins naturally have a lively, fruity acidity that connoisseurs appreciate, think notes of berry, citrus or apple. That is a very different experience from the flat, sharp sourness of a badly brewed cup. Want to learn to recognise those fresh flavour notes yourself? Then read our explanation in tasting coffee: how to recognise flavour notes like a barista or discover more about where your beans come from in single origin coffee: what is it and why does it taste the way it does?.
No more risk of sour coffee: start with fresh beans
However well you brew, with old or badly roasted beans it remains hard to get a balanced cup. At SIJL we roast our coffee in small batches on Gedempte Singel in Assen, so you always start with fresh beans, at home or on the go.
Browse our full range of freshly roasted coffee beans in the webshop and make a conscious choice for a fruity, sweet or traditional flavour profile, so you know exactly what you're bringing home. If you're near Assen, Groningen or Meppel, feel free to drop by our coffee bar on Gedempte Singel and let our baristas help you with the right brewing method. All the practical information for a visit, such as our opening hours and location, is on our website.
Frequently asked questions about sour coffee
Why does my filter coffee taste sour but my espresso doesn't?
Filter coffee is more sensitive to under-extraction because the water only passes through it once. With espresso the coffee is brewed under pressure, which leads to a fuller extraction more quickly, although espresso can taste sour too if the grind is too coarse or the shot time too short.
Can the quality of the water affect a sour taste?
Yes, water with a low mineral content extracts less well, so coffee can taste flat and sour sooner. Ordinary tap water in the Netherlands is usually fine, but preferably use fresh water without a strong smell or taste.
Why did my coffee taste good at first and now suddenly sour?
Often it's down to the beans: the longer coffee is kept after the roast date, the more aroma it loses and the more the flavour shifts. Store your beans airtight and cool, and preferably buy an amount you'll finish within two to three weeks.
Is sour coffee unhealthy or just less tasty?
Sour coffee caused by under-extraction isn't unhealthy; it's purely a matter of taste and balance. If you have a sensitive stomach, a cup that's too sour can feel unsettling sooner. In that case a slightly longer extraction and a less light roast often help.
Which grind size should I use if my coffee keeps tasting sour?
Start by grinding one small step finer than you're used to and taste again before adjusting further. You'll find a full overview per brewing method in our article on the right grind size.