Guests standing at the display case of our chocolaterie often have the same question: what actually is the difference between dark, milk and white chocolate? The answer lies mainly in the cocoa content and in what else goes into the bar or bonbon. In this article the chocolatiers of SIJL in Assen explain exactly how the three types differ, how to taste which one suits you, and why a good bonbon can start with any of the three. That way you'll choose with confidence from now on, whether you're opening a bar at home or picking out a box of fresh bonbons.
What is the difference between dark, milk and white chocolate?
In short: the difference lies in the ratio of cocoa, milk and sugar. Dark chocolate contains cocoa mass and cocoa butter with no added milk. Milk chocolate adds milk powder, which makes the flavour softer and sweeter. White chocolate contains only cocoa butter, milk and sugar, so no cocoa mass, and that gives it its characteristic creamy colour and flavour.
Those three building blocks determine everything: the colour, how it melts, the sweetness and how intense the chocolate tastes. Once you've grasped that, you immediately understand why an eighty per cent dark chocolate eats so differently from a creamy white bonbon.
What is dark chocolate and how much cocoa is in it?
Dark chocolate consists mainly of cocoa mass and cocoa butter, with a little sugar added. The higher the cocoa content, the more intense and less sweet the flavour. Most dark chocolate sits between fifty and ninety per cent cocoa.
At around seventy per cent you often taste a lovely balance: robust and rich in cocoa, but not yet bitter. Move towards eighty or ninety per cent and notes of coffee, roasted nuts, red fruit or even earth come forward, depending on the origin of the bean. Just as with specialty coffee, the origin of the cocoa determines the flavour profile. We notice that guests who like a punchy espresso often fall for a dark chocolate with character too. If you'd like to try that combination, read our tips on how to combine bonbons with coffee.
What makes milk chocolate so soft?
Milk chocolate owes its soft, creamy flavour to added milk powder. As a result the cocoa content is lower, usually between thirty and forty per cent, and you taste more sweetness and a velvety texture.
For many people milk chocolate is the familiar taste of childhood: approachable, mild and comforting. Yet here too there is a world of difference between mass production and craft. A good milk chocolate uses real cocoa butter and quality milk, so you still taste the cocoa rather than only sugar. In our chocolaterie on Gedempte Singel in Assen we deliberately work with milk chocolate that isn't bland or overly sweet, so that the filling of a bonbon can play the leading role.
Is white chocolate really chocolate?
White chocolate contains no cocoa mass, but it does contain cocoa butter, and that is the fat that comes from the cocoa bean. That is why it may officially be called chocolate, even though it lacks the brown colour and the cocoa flavour. In good white chocolate you mainly taste cream, vanilla and a sweet, full finish.
Precisely because white chocolate is a neutral, creamy canvas, it lends itself wonderfully to bonbons with fruit, caramel, matcha or spices. The flavour of the filling really comes into its own in it. Lesser white chocolate uses vegetable fats instead of cocoa butter, and you taste that straight away: vaguer, greasier and less refined. So when you're choosing a gift it pays to ask what the white chocolate is made of.
Which chocolate contains the most cocoa and the least sugar?
Dark chocolate has the highest cocoa content and contains the least sugar; milk and white chocolate are sweeter and creamier. Chocolate remains a treat, and enjoying it in moderation is the starting point.
Our advice is simple: rather choose a small piece of high-quality chocolate than a big bar that consists mostly of sugar. An intense dark chocolate or a carefully made bonbon gives so much flavour that a little is already enough. That fits the way we look at coffee and chocolate: better mindful and good than a lot and mediocre.
Which chocolate suits which moment?
Dark chocolate is ideal after dinner, with a cup of coffee or when you really want to take the time to taste. Milk chocolate is the safe favourite with tea, for children or as a moment of comfort. White chocolate shines in combination with fresh fruit or as a playful accent in a mixed box of bonbons.
Not sure when putting together a gift? Then go for variety. A box with dark, milk and white bonbons lets the person receiving it discover their own favourite. That's why in our bonbon boxes we deliberately combine different types of chocolate and fillings. If you want to know why fresh bonbons are always a good gift, read our article on giving chocolate as a gift with fresh bonbons.
How to store dark, milk and white chocolate
All three types are best stored cool, dry and dark, between about twelve and eighteen degrees, and away from strong smells. White and milk chocolate are a little more delicate because they contain milk, so those are best eaten a bit sooner.
Don't put chocolate in the fridge between the cheese and the onions, because cocoa butter easily takes on smells. A cool pantry is better. Want to know more about shelf life and the right place to store them? We wrote a detailed guide on it: how to store bonbons so they stay fresh for as long as possible.
Frequently asked questions about dark, milk and white chocolate
What is the main difference between dark and milk chocolate?
Dark chocolate contains no milk and has a higher cocoa content, which makes the flavour more intense and less sweet. Milk chocolate contains milk powder and is therefore softer, creamier and sweeter.
Does white chocolate contain cocoa?
White chocolate contains cocoa butter, the fat from the cocoa bean, but no cocoa mass. That is why it lacks the brown colour and the typical cocoa flavour, but may still be called chocolate.
Which chocolate tastes best?
That is a matter of taste. If you like intense and grown-up, dark chocolate is your choice. If you're looking for soft and familiar, milk chocolate is a good fit. For creamy and playful, white chocolate is ideal. The nicest thing is to taste them side by side.
Can I have dark, milk and white chocolate delivered throughout the Netherlands?
Yes. We send our fresh bonbons with dark, milk and white chocolate by post throughout the Netherlands, so you can enjoy our chocolate outside Assen and Drenthe too.
Taste the difference at SIJL in Assen
In the end you only really understand the difference between dark, milk and white chocolate when you taste them side by side. So do drop by our chocolaterie and coffee bar on Gedempte Singel in the centre of Assen, where you can compare all three with a freshly brewed cup of coffee alongside. Want to enjoy them at home or surprise someone? Then order our fresh bonbon boxes in the webshop, which we deliver throughout the Netherlands. And sign up for our newsletter to be the first to hear when we launch new flavours and seasonal bonbons.